Let the Laser Win

An article by Dr. Irit Juwiler and Prof. Jacob Gavan

Our security forces have impressive success intercepting Qassam and other rockets from the Gaza Strip and contending with the tunnel threat, but a solution to the incendiary balloons and the drones has yet to be found. Gaza found a simple method at a low cost - sending kites or balloons with incendiary material, explosives and even more dangerous munitions that burn fields, destroy plant and animal life and endanger civilians and soldiers.

Up to now tens of thousands of dunams have been burned, heavy damage for a small country such as ours. This week we were informed of more incendiary balloons sent from Gaza.

Current kinetic defense systems, including the Iron Dome system, are ineffective against the incendiary balloons, and a national effort is needed to find an effective and ethical solution to address this threat.

Laser systems can be an ideal solution for eliminating the threat of balloons and drones, and in the future even precise missiles. The balloons or kites sent across the border are carried by the wind at a speed significantly slower than the speed of sound. The speed of the laser beam on the other hand is much faster, almost equal to the speed of light. Thus the incendiary balloons can be shot down while still in enemy territory, within a short period of time, with high certainty and high precision, without harming the children sent to fly the balloons.

In addition to being a more effective and precise weapon, the economic cost of using a laser, in other words the consumption of electrical energy, is very low compared to the high cost of mechanical bullets.

In the past Israel was a pioneer in developing laser weapons against Qassams and missiles. The NAUTILUS Project was launched jointly with the U.S. Defense Department and companies such as Rafael, Elbit and the Israel Aerospace Industries in 1996 in the aim of developing and manufacturing chemical laser cannons. Trial results were encouraging, however the technology was not fully developed at the time and the project was discontinued in 2005. Kinetic weapon systems were developed instead - the Iron Dome, David’s Sling and the Hetz (Arrow) systems, which although operative are costly and slow. 

In light of current increased manufacturing of high-speed and precise missiles in large quantities and threats from Iran and the Hezbollah, there is an urgent need to return to the development and production of laser weapon systems which have advanced in the interim.

In any case, Iron Dome and the other existing systems will remain vital as there is no substitute for them in the meantime. What’s more, they will continue to provide protection when the effectiveness of laser systems decreases under bad weather and atmospheric conditions and on rainy and cloudy days. Nonetheless, there is an urgent need to develop and produce powerful laser cannons and to combine them with existing kinetic systems.

The State of Israel must get to work and invest efforts. Similar to the national technological effort to eliminate the threat of the tunnels, there is now an existential need for a national effort to design, develop and produce energy weapon systems of the fiber laser, chemical laser and microwave type. These will operate in combination with existing kinetic systems against the threat of a barrage of rapid and even supersonic missiles. This must be carried out in cooperation with the U.S. government and leading security companies in this field. This is the current need, and should be one of the national undertakings of the next government and Knesset of Israel, in order to ensure the life of the people living in Zion and to prevent large-scale destruction and countless casualties.